This is “Advertising and Social Networks: A occupational in Progress”, ar 7.6 indigenous the book Getting the many Out of information Systems: A Manager's guide (v. 1.0). For details on that (including licensing), click here.

This book is licensed under a an innovative Commons by-nc-sa 3.0 license. Check out the license for an ext details, yet that basically method you deserve to share this publication as lengthy as you credit the author (but watch below), don"t do money native it, and do make it accessible to everyone else under the exact same terms.

This content was available as the December 29, 2012, and it was downloaded then by Andy Schmitz in an effort to preserve the accessibility of this book.

Normally, the author and publisher would be attributed here. However, the publisher has actually asked for the customary an innovative Commons attribution come the original publisher, authors, title, and book URI to be removed. Additionally, every the publisher"s request, their name has actually been removed in part passages. More information is obtainable on this project"s attribution page.

For an ext information ~ above the resource of this book, or why that is obtainable for free, please view the project"s home page. You deserve to browse or download added books there. To download a .zip paper containing this book to usage offline, simply click here.

has this book helped you? take into consideration passing that on:

Help an imaginative Commons
creative Commons supports free culture from music to education. Your licenses aided make this book accessible to you.

Help a publicly School helps human being like you help teachers money their classroom projects, from art gives to publications to calculators.
Previous ar
Table of materials
next Section

7.6 Advertising and Social Networks: A work-related in Progress

Learning Objectives

After examining this ar you should have the ability to do the following:

define the distinctions in the Facebook and also Google advertisement models. Define the Hunt versus Hike metaphor, contrast the loved one success of advertisement performance ~ above search compared to social networks, and understand the determinants behind the latter’s struggles. Recognize just how firms space leveraging social networks because that brand and also product engagement, be able to carry out examples of successful efforts, and give factors why such engagement is difficult to achieve.

If facebook is going to proceed to provide away its services for free, it needs to do money somehow. Right currently that way advertising. Happily for the firm, online advertising is hot. For years, online advertising has been the only significant media category that has seen an increase in safety (see thing 8 "Google: Search, virtual Advertising, and Beyond…"). And while 20 percent the media intake happens online, the web attracts just 6 percent of declaring dollars, saying there’s lot of of growth still ahead.Bryant Urstadt, “The organization of society Networks,” Technology Review, July/August 2008. That company spend much more advertising online than they execute on radio ads, and the net will quickly beat out spending top top cable TV and also magazine ads.Mark Sweeney, “Internet ad Spending will certainly Overtake tv in 2009,” Guardian, may 19, 2008. However not all Internet declaring is developed equal. And also there are indications that society networking sites are struggling to find the right ad model.

You are watching: Facebook enjoys significantly higher click-through rates than google.

In early on 2008, Google founder Sergey Brin stated, “I nothing think we have the killer best way to advertise and monetize society networks yet.” Brin walk on to state that social networking ad inventory together a entirety was prove problematic and also that the “monetization occupational we were doing there didn’t pan out and also we had actually hoped.”“Everywhere and Nowhere,” Economist, in march 19, 2008. Once Google advertisement partner Fox interaction Media (the News Corporation division that includes MySpace) announced the revenue would autumn one hundred million dollars short of projections, News Corporation’s stock tumbled 5 percent, analysts downgraded the company, and the firm’s chief revenue officer to be dismissed.Brian Stelter, “MySpace can Have Friends, yet It Wants ad Money,” New York Times, June 16, 2008.

Why aren’t social networks having the success the Google and also other sites? troubles advertising on this sites encompass content adjacencyConcern that an advertisement will certainly run near offensive material, embarrassing one advertiser and/or degrading their products or brands., and user attention. The content adjacency difficulty refers to concern over wherein a that company advertisements will certainly run. Look at at every one of the creepy title in society networking news groups. Do advertisers really want their ads running alongside conversations that are racy, offensive, illegal, or the may even mock their products? This potential location junxtap is a major problem with any type of site giving ads nearby to free-form social media. Summing up industry wariness, one P&G manager said, “What in heaven’s surname made you think you might monetize the real estate in which somebody is breaking up with their girlfriend?”B. Stone, “Facebook aims to extends Its Reach across Web,” New York Times, December 1, 2008. An IDC report argues that it’s due to the fact that of content adjacency that “brand advertisers largely think about user-generated contents as low-quality, brand-unsafe inventory” for running ads.R. Stross, “Advertisers challenge Hurdles on social Networking Sites,” New York Times, December 14, 2008.

Now let’s look at the user attention problem.

Attention Challenges: The Hunt matches The Hike

In terms of revenue model, on facebook is radically different from Google and the hot-growth category of find advertising. Customers of Google and also other search sites room on a hunt—a task-oriented expedition to collect info that will drive a certain action. Search customers want to learn something, purchase something, research study a problem, or acquire a inquiry answered. To the level that the hunting overlaps with ads, the works. Simply searched ~ above a clinical term? Google will display you an ad from a drug company. Searching for a toy? You’ll view Google ads indigenous eBay sellers and other digital shops. Kind in a holidays destination and also you acquire a long list that ads indigenous travel service providers aggressively courting your spending. Even better, Google just charges message advertisers when a user clicks through. No clicks? The ad runs at no price to the firm. Indigenous a return on invest perspective, this is extraordinarily efficient. How regularly do users click on Google ads? sufficient for this to it is in the single most financially rewarding activity amongst any net firm. In 2008, Google revenue totaled virtually twenty-two exchange rate dollars. Revenues exceeded $4.2 billion, almost every one of this from pay-per-click ads (see thing 8 "Google: Search, virtual Advertising, and also Beyond…" for an ext details).

While users go to Google come hunt, they walk to facebook as if they were going on a hike—they have actually a unstable idea that what they’ll encounter, yet they’re over there to explore and also look around, reap the sights (or site). They’ve typically allocated time for fun and they don’t desire to leaving the terrain once they’re having actually conversations, looking at photos or videos, and checking out updates from friends.

These intake patterns space reflected in click-through rates. Google users click ads approximately 2 percent of the moment (and at a much higher rate when searching for product information). At Facebook, click-throughs are about 0.04 percent.Bryant Urstadt, “The service of social Networks,” Technology Review, July/August 2008. Prices quoted in this item seem high, but a huge discrepancy in between site prices holds across reported data.

Most banner ads don’t fee per click, however rather via something called CPMCost every thousand impressions (the M representing the roman numeral for one thousand).—that’s cost per thousands impressionsEach time an ad is served to a user because that viewing. (an impression being every time an advertisement appears ~ above someone’s screen). The divine grail that Internet declaring is targeting. The an ext focused one audience, the much more likely a firm is to lure advertisers willing to salary a greater CPM to with those users. Prices vary widely. In 2008, MySpace lowered its banner ad rate indigenous $3.25 CPM to much less than two dollars. Through contrast, TechTarget, a internet publisher concentrating on modern technology professionals, is able come command CPM rates of one hundreds dollars and above (an advertisement inventory that an useful helped the firm go public in 2007). Technology Review magazine boasts a CPM that seventy dollars. The social networking blog Mashable has CPM rates ranging between seven and thirty-three dollars. However Facebook ads go for much, lot less. Lookery, a one-time ad network the bought ad space on facebook in bulk, had actually been reselling inventory in ~ a CPM of 7.5 cents (note that facebook does offer advertisers pay-per-click and impression-based, or CPM, options). Even Facebook ads v a little bit of targeting are poorly priced (Facebook’s society Ads, which permit advertisers to target customers according to location and age, have a floor price that fifteen cent CPM).Bryant Urstadt, “The business of social Networks,” Technology Review, July/August 2008; Jessi Hempel, “Finding cracks in Facebook,” Fortune, might 13, 2008; and also E. Schonfeld, “Are on facebook Ads Going come Zero? Lookery Lowers Its insurance to 7.5-cent CMPs,” TechCrunch, July 22, 2008.

Getting creative with Promotions: Does that Work?

Facebook and also other social networks space still discovering what works. Advertisement inventory presented on high-traffic house pages have actually garnered large bucks for firms choose Yahoo! with MySpace and also Facebook supplying advertisers higher audience reach than most network television programs, there’s small reason to suggest that chunks the this business won’t ultimately flow come the society networks. However even much more interesting is just how Facebook and also widget web page have begun to experiment with relatively brand-new forms that advertising. Many feel that Facebook has actually a unique opportunity to obtain consumers to interact with your brand, and some early experiments allude where this might be heading.

Figure 7.2


The Disney Backlot area top top Facebook has contests, movie trailers, reviews, and upcoming releases. Individuals can additionally “become a fan,” and get accessibility to development screenings, premiere tickets, methods to meet the stars, access time to movie sets, and also other freebies.

Many firms have been leveraging so-called engagement adsPromotion an approach popular through social media the attempts to obtain consumers to communicate with an ad, then shares that activity with friends. Through making their products part of the on facebook fun. COO Sheryl Sandberg disputed Ben and Jerry’s promo for the ice cream cream chain’s complimentary cone day event. To promote the upcoming event, Ben and also Jerry’s initially contracted come make 2 hundred and fifty thousand “gift cones” available to on facebook users; they could click on tiny icons that would gift a cone icon to a friend, and that would display up in your profile. Within a couple of hours, customers had sent all two hundred and fifty thousand online cones. Delighted, Ben and Jerry’s bought one more two hundred and also fifty thousands cones. Within eleven hours, half a million world had sent cones, countless making plans with Facebook friends to attend the real totally free cone day. The job of the on facebook promotion, Ben and also Jerry’s internet site registered fifty-three million impressions, together users looked for store locations and also wrote around their favorite flavors.Quentin Hardy, “Facebook Thinks outside Boxes,” Forbes, may 28, 2008. The campaign dovetailed with everything Facebook was great at: it was viral, generating enthusiasm for a promotion event and even prompting scheduling.

In various other promotions, great Pictures offered away two hundred and also fifty thousand digital fedoras for “Indiana Jones and also the Kingdom of the decision Skull.” They sold out within hours, v users rallying friends, family, and colleagues to check out the movie. Honda gave away 3 quarters of a million hearts throughout Valentine’s work 2009.S. Sandberg, “Sheryl Sandberg ~ above Facebook’s Future,” BusinessWeek, April 8, 2009. The Dr. Pepper Snapple Group offered two hundred and fifty thousand online Sunkist sodas, i beg your pardon earned the for sure one hundred thirty million brand impressions in twenty-two hours. Says Sunkist’s brand manager, “A Super bowl ad, if you compare it, would have produced somewhere in between six to 7 million.”Elaine Wong, “Ben & Jerry’s, Sunkist, Indy Jones Unwrap Facebook’s ‘Gift the Gab,’” Brandweek, June 1, 2008.

Of course, also with this business, facebook may uncover that that competes with widget makers. Slide also offers wacky heralding programs v its very own Facebook apps (the firm sits atop the most popular application developer rankings). Fox Searchlight checked out Slide to enable friends to litter orange Tic Tacs at each other as component of a promotion for the movie “Juno.” Coke used Slide come distribute digital Vitamin Water. By some estimates, in 2009, Facebook application developers absorbed well over half a exchange rate dollars—exceeding Facebook’s very own haul.M. Learmonth and A. Klaasen, “Facebook Apps will Make an ext Money 보다 Facebook in 2009,” Silicon Alley Insider, may 18, 2009. Unlike Apple’s app store (where lot of developer-earned revenue originates from selling apps), the vast bulk of on facebook apps are free and ad-supported. That way Facebook and also its application providers room in competition come monetize on facebook users, and also both room running at a finite pot that recession-constrained heralding dollars.

While this efforts can be quirky and fun, space they also effective? some of these programs are considered successes; others, not so much. Jupiter research surveyed marketers do the efforts to develop a viral impact online and also found the only about 15 percent that these efforts actually caught on v consumers.Matt Cowan, “Marketers struggle to obtain Social,” Reuters, June 19, 2008, If the Ben and also Jerry’s gift cones were used up quickly, a visit to facebook in the weeks after ~ this project saw CareerBuilder, large Eye Caffeinated Spirits, and Coors Light icons lingering job after their first appearance. Brand seeking to deploy their very own applications in on facebook have also struggled. New Media Age reported the applications rolled the end by optimal brands such together MTV, Warner Brothers, and Woolworths were discovered to have as small as five daily users. Congestion may be setting in because that all but the many innovative applications, together standing the end in a group of end twenty-three thousand applications becomes increasingly difficult.L. Goldie, “For on facebook Success Brands must Stand Out” New Media Age, might 1, 2008.

To that is credit, consumer commodities giant P&G has actually been relentlessly exploring with leveraging social networks for brand engagement, yet the results present what a difficult slog this deserve to be. The firm go garner fourteen thousand facebook “fans” for its crest Whitestrips product, but those fans to be earned while giving away totally free movie tickets and also other promos. The New York Times quipped that v those kinds of incentives, “even a hemorrhoid cream” can have attractive a comparable group of “fans,” and also when the giveaways stopped, thousands promptly “unfanned” Whitestrips. Outcomes for Proctor and also Gamble’s “2X Ultra Tide” fan page were also pretty grim. P&G do the efforts offbeat appeals for customer-brand bonding, consisting of asking Facebookers to short article “their favorite areas to gain stain-making moments.” but a examine eleven months after launch had actually garnered simply eighteen submissions, two from P&G, 2 from staffers at spoof news site The Onion, and also a bunch that short articles such as “Tidealicious!”R. Stross, “Advertisers challenge Hurdles on social Networking Sites,” New York Times, December 14, 2008.

See more: Which Switch Features Are Typically Used With Voip And How Does It Work?

Efforts about engagement opportunities like occasions (Ben and Jerry’s) or commodities consumer are anxious to identify themselves with (a tape or a movie) might have much more success 보다 trying come promote customer goods the otherwise offer little allegiance, however efforts are so brand-new that metrics space scarce, affect is hard to gauge, and best practices are still unclear.